1.
 
 LOUISVILLE
  
Keyshawn Johnson
USC - 1st Round (1)
WR NYJ
2.
 
 TENNESSEE
  
Tim Biakabutuka
Michigan - 1st Round (8)
RB CAR
3.
 
 CHARLESTON
   Pick acquired from Richmond
Lawrence Phillips
Nebraska - 1st Round (6)
RB STL
4.
 
 TALLAHASSEE
  
Terry Glenn
Ohio State - 1st Round (7)
WR NE
5.
 
 FLORIDA
   Pick acquired from TAB thru TAL*
Marvin Harrison
Syracuse - 1st Round (19)
WR IND
6.
 
 POMPANO BEACH
   Pick acquired from
Jacksonville
Eddie George
Ohio State - 1st Round (14)
RB HOU
7.
 
 POMPANO BEACH
   Pick acquired from
Arizona
Bobby Engram
Penn State - 2nd Round (52)
WR CHI
8.
 
 MANHATTAN
  
Rickey Dudley
Ohio State - 1st Round (9)
TE OAK
9.
 
 FLORIDA
   Pick acquired from Pompano Beach
Leeland McElroy
Texas A&M - 2nd Round (32)
RB ARZ
10.
 
 SANTA ROSA
  
Derrick Mayes
Notre Dame - 2nd Round (36)
WR GB
11.
 
 RICHMOND
   Pick acquired from Charleston
Jason Dunn
Eastern Kentucky - 2nd Round (54)
TE PHI
12.
 
 BAKERSFIELD
  
Muhsin Muhammad
Michigan State - 2nd Round (43)
WR CAR
13.
 
 WEST VIRGINIA
  
Eddie Kennison
LSU - 1st Round (18)
WR STL
14.
 
 TALLAHASSEE
   Pick acquired from Atlanta
Eric Moulds
Mississippi State - 1st Round (24)
WR BUF
15.
 
 FLORIDA
  
Bryan Still
Virginia Tech - 2nd Round (41)
WR SD
16.
 
 WASHINGTON
  
Amani Toomer
Michigan - 2nd Round (34)
WR NYG
17.
 
 SAN FRANCISCO
  Pick acquired from SFS thru FLA
Moe Williams
Kentucky - 3rd Round (75)
RB MIN

* - Compensatory pick awarded to Tallahassee due to a trade they had made with Tampa Bay prior to the team folding

April 1996